Here’s a strange one. Show people two photos of the same face, both upside down. One is a normal photo. In the other, the eyes and mouth have been cut out and flipped. Most people say the two look about the same. Turn them right side up, and the edited face looks wrong instantly. You looked straight at the problem, and it seemed fine.
You’ve done the same thing with something that cost real money. You read the offer, every piece of it looked fine, and you said yes. Then the first bill showed up and turned the whole thing right side up.
I spent 30 years in marketing building offers like that, so I’ve sat on the side of the table that decides which part of a deal you see first. Here’s why the trick works on your eyes, where the same move shows up at checkout and in arguments, and a two-move check called the Flip Test.
The upside-down face test
A psychologist named Peter Thompson first showed this in 1980. He used a photo of Britain’s prime minister at the time, Margaret Thatcher, which is why researchers still call it the Thatcher effect. It works on any face, which is why the video uses mine.
Why every part passes
When a face is right side up, you take it in as a whole. You don’t check the eyes, then the nose, then the mouth. You see how they all sit together, and when one part is turned the wrong way, the whole face looks wrong right away.
Turn the face upside down and that whole-face check gets much weaker. You fall back to looking at the parts one at a time. On their own, those parts looked normal, because the flipped eyes and mouth were sitting right side up on the screen. Each part passed, and nothing checked the whole.
To be honest about it, researchers still argue about exactly why this happens, and some think part of it comes from a later judgment step, after the seeing is done. What nobody argues about is the result: turn the picture over, and an obvious problem gets past you.
The checkout version
A photo of a face costs you nothing. It starts costing you money the moment someone else decides which part of a price you see first.
In 2015, StubHub, the ticket site, ran an experiment on its own customers. Millions of buyers in the U.S. were split at random into two groups. One group saw the full price of a ticket, fees included, from the first page. The other saw the ticket price first and the fees only at checkout. Same tickets, and the same total at the end. The group that saw the fees late spent about 21% more, and they were about 14% more likely to buy at all.
That’s the Thatcher effect at a checkout. The ticket price is the part you check, and it looks right. The total is the whole, and by the time it shows up, you’ve already decided.
The fair point on the other side: a lower first number makes it easier to browse and compare, and the total does appear before you pay. The catch is when it appears. You check the whole after you’ve already made up your mind.
The question test
Answer this as fast as you can: how many animals of each kind did Moses take on the ark?
Most people say two. Moses didn’t build the ark. Noah did. Researchers call this the Moses illusion. In the first study of it, in 1981, people answered questions like this one without noticing the wrong name about half the time, and these were people who knew the real story. Every other piece of the question sounded familiar, so the wrong piece rode along with the rest.
When the label is your team
The familiar part can also be the name of your own team. In 2003, a psychologist named Geoffrey Cohen ran a study with college students who described themselves as liberal or conservative. He asked them to judge a welfare plan. One version was generous, and one was strict.
With no labels, people judged the way you’d expect: liberals liked the generous plan, conservatives liked the strict one. Then Cohen told them which party backed the plan, and that one label beat everything else. Liberals backed the strict plan when told Democrats supported it. Conservatives backed the generous plan when told Republicans supported it. Asked about it afterward, they said the label hadn’t affected them.
It ran in both directions, so nobody gets to read this and decide it’s only the other side. One honest note: this is an older study with college students, so treat it as a clear demonstration of the move, not a measurement of everybody.
The Flip Test
I put this on a free one-page card you can print or keep on your phone: The Flip Test Card.
Move one: cover the smile. When something gives you that quick feeling of yes, ask which one or two pieces are doing the work. Maybe it’s a low first price, or the name of a group you already trust. Cover those up in your head and look at what’s left.
Move two: turn it right side up. Put the whole thing in your format instead of theirs. For a deal, that means one number: the total you’ll pay from start to finish, fees and renewals included. For an argument, it means swapping the label. Keep everything about the plan the same, and change who’s behind it to a group you don’t trust. If your answer changes, the label was doing your thinking.
Two moves, about ten seconds, and you’re looking at the whole face instead of the parts.
When the shortcut is fine
Checking parts instead of the whole is usually fine. Most familiar things are safe, and if you checked every receipt and every sentence from scratch, you’d never get through a day. Save the Flip Test for the moments when someone else picked which part you’d see first, and your money or your vote is on the line.
I learned this one the hard way. My first job out of college was as a case manager, approving medication reimbursements on injury claims. One day I looked at the total, read a few of the medications, saw the list had been approved before, and approved it. My supervisor caught it: one of those medications had nothing to do with the injury. I should have held every medication up against the doctor’s report. The report was the whole face, and I only checked the parts.
Questions people ask
What is the Thatcher effect?
It’s an illusion where a face with its eyes and mouth flipped upside down looks almost normal when the whole picture is upside down, then looks grotesque the moment it’s turned right side up. Psychologist Peter Thompson first showed it in 1980.
Why is it called the Thatcher effect?
Peter Thompson’s original 1980 demonstration used a photo of Margaret Thatcher, Britain’s prime minister at the time. The name stuck, but the effect works on any face.
Why don’t we notice the flipped eyes and mouth upside down?
Upright, people judge a face as a whole, so one part turned the wrong way stands out. Upside down, that whole-face check weakens and people look at the parts one at a time, and each flipped part looks normal on its own. Researchers still debate the exact reason, but the result is well established.
Do hidden fees make people spend more?
In a randomized test on StubHub with millions of U.S. buyers, people who saw ticket fees only at checkout spent about 21% more and were about 14% more likely to buy than people who saw the full price upfront. The tickets and the final total were the same.
What is the Moses illusion?
It’s the tendency to answer “How many animals of each kind did Moses take on the ark?” without noticing that it was Noah, not Moses. In the first study, in 1981, people missed the wrong name about half the time, even when they knew the story.
Sources
- Thompson, P. (1980). Margaret Thatcher: A new illusion. Perception 9(4), 483–484.
- Bartlett, J. C. & Searcy, J. (1993). Inversion and configuration of faces. Cognitive Psychology 25(3), 281–316.
- Blake, T., Moshary, S., Sweeney, K. & Tadelis, S. (2021). Price salience and product choice. Marketing Science 40(4).
- Erickson, T. D. & Mattson, M. E. (1981). From words to meaning: A semantic illusion. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 20(5), 540–551.
- Cohen, G. L. (2003). Party over policy: The dominating impact of group influence on political beliefs. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 85(5), 808–822.
