• Home
  • Think Sharper
  • The Second Myth
  • Tech in Plain English
  • Free Tools
  • About
  • Newsletter
  • Menu Menu
Allen Stafford — Think Sharper
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to Youtube

Tag Archive for: iau planet definition

The Second Myth, Words That Lie Season 1

You Were Taught Wrong About Pluto. Here’s Why

Why is Pluto not a planet? Ask around and you’ll get one of two answers.

The popular one: in 2006, scientists took a closer look at Pluto, realized it wasn’t really a planet, and kicked it out of the club. Poor little guy.

The smart one: Pluto’s a dwarf planet. Science settled it. Get over it.

The first answer is wrong. The second is about half right. Scientists didn’t discover anything new about Pluto in 2006. What changed was a word.

The little guy at the end of the line

On February 18, 1930, at Lowell Observatory in Arizona, 24-year-old Clyde Tombaugh found Pluto by doing one of the most tedious jobs in science: comparing photographs of the night sky, looking for one tiny dot that moved. He was born in Illinois and came to Lowell from his family’s farm in Kansas. The name came from Venetia Burney, an 11-year-old schoolgirl in Oxford, England, who suggested the Roman god of the underworld. Lowell’s staff voted for it unanimously.

For the next 76 years, Pluto was the ninth planet: on every poster, in every textbook, the underdog at the end of the line. So when 2006 came, people took it personally. The American Dialect Society made “plutoed” its word of the year, meaning to demote or devalue someone or something.

What the correction gets right

Pluto really is small. It has less than a fifth of the mass of our Moon, and our estimates of it spent most of a century collapsing. The “Planet X” that astronomers were hunting in 1915 was predicted to be about seven times the mass of Earth. Right after the discovery, Pluto was estimated at about one Earth. By 1948, it was a tenth of one. Then in 1978, astronomers found Pluto’s moon Charon, and a moon lets you weigh the thing it orbits. The answer was about 0.2 percent of Earth’s mass.

Then, in 2005, astronomers found Eris, a world out past Pluto with about a quarter more mass. That forced the issue. If Pluto is a planet, Eris has to be one too, and more icy worlds were turning up out there.

So on August 24, 2006, in Prague, the International Astronomical Union (IAU) voted on an official definition. A planet must orbit the Sun, have enough mass to pull itself into a nearly round shape, and have “cleared the neighbourhood around its orbit.” Pluto passes the first two tests. It fails the third, because it shares its zone with the icy bodies of the Kuiper Belt.

What “science settled it” leaves out

In 2006, nothing about Pluto changed: not its size, not its orbit, not one atom. Before that vote, “planet” had no official scientific definition at all. Pluto wasn’t caught being a fake planet. The word got a definition for the first time, and Pluto didn’t fit it.

And the settling was done by about 420 astronomers holding up yellow cards in a hall in Prague, under 5 percent of the IAU’s membership. The planet definition itself passed by a large majority without a formal count. The resolution naming Pluto a dwarf planet was counted: 237 for, 157 against, 17 abstaining.

Astronomers holding up yellow voting cards at the 2006 IAU General Assembly in Prague.

Astronomers holding up yellow voting cards at the 2006 IAU General Assembly in Prague.” (Press photos from the vote are credited to IAU/Lars Holm Nielsen

Plenty of astronomers objected. The loudest was Alan Stern, who was already leading NASA’s New Horizons mission. His spacecraft had launched for the ninth planet seven months before the vote. Stern went straight at the third test. “It rules out Jupiter, because Jupiter has Trojan asteroids,” he said. “It rules out Neptune, because Pluto crosses Neptune’s orbit.” And: “If you put Earth out in the Kuiper Belt, it couldn’t clear it either.” About 300 scientists signed a petition within days. It ended with a blunt line: “A better definition is needed.”

Stern had a stake in the word in another way, too. He’d used the term “dwarf planet” back in the 1990s, to mean a small kind of planet. Under the IAU’s definition, a dwarf planet isn’t a planet at all.

Why “it was only a vote” goes too far

This is where it’s easy to overcorrect, and this channel exists to catch exactly that. The line wasn’t arbitrary.

The IAU’s defenders say the rule was never meant to require a perfectly empty orbit. Steven Soter, an astrophysicist at the American Museum of Natural History, proposed measuring how much a body dominates the mass in its orbital zone. By his measures, a gap of about five orders of magnitude, a factor of around 100,000, separates the eight planets from the asteroids and Kuiper Belt objects. Stern and his colleague Harold Levison had found the same kind of gap in 2002. They just treated the two groups as two kinds of planet. And Mike Brown, whose team found Eris, argued that “the concept is more important than a lawyerly reading of the definition.”

As for the turnout complaint, Daniel Fischer, the science writer who put the voters at perhaps 1 percent of the world’s working astronomers, covered the meeting in person and defended the outcome. The voters, he wrote, had just been through a week of intense argument.

So the gap is real physics. Whether “planet” should stop at that gap isn’t physics. It’s a choice about a word, and reasonable astronomers still make it differently. It’s a dictionary fight with telescopes.

This has happened before

On New Year’s Day, 1801, Giuseppe Piazzi discovered Ceres, and it was hailed as a new planet. Then came Pallas, Juno and Vesta. An introductory textbook from 1828 listed eleven planets. By 1850, astronomers were counting about twenty, thirteen of them what we now call asteroids.

Then they stopped. The standard account, from James Hilton of the U.S. Naval Observatory, says asteroids came to be seen as a separate class in the 1850s and 1860s, once they proved too small and too numerous. A 2019 paper by Philip Metzger, Mark Sykes, Alan Stern and Kirby Runyon argues that astronomers kept calling them planets for another century, and only stopped in the 1950s as evidence about their geology came in. The video tells the first version. Either way, your ancestors had to un-learn planets too, and nobody made “Ceresed” the word of the year.

Some people don’t let it go. In 2009, the Illinois Senate, in Tombaugh’s birth state, adopted a resolution saying that “as Pluto passes overhead through Illinois’ night skies,” it should “be reestablished with full planetary status.” So, technically, Pluto is a planet. Over Illinois.

It hasn’t stopped there. In March 2026, NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman told the Daily Mail he supports restoring Pluto’s planet status. But the definition belongs to the IAU, an independent international body, and no government can vote on it. As of the 20th anniversary in August 2026, Pluto was still officially a dwarf planet.

The wrong question

So who’s right, the people who say Pluto is a planet or the people who say it isn’t? That turns out not to be a question about Pluto. Both sides agree on its size, its orbit and its neighbors. They disagree about where to draw a line on a label we invented.

It’s the same fight as whether a tomato is a fruit. Botanically, yes. In your salad, it’s a vegetable. Nobody’s wrong about the tomato.

What everyone missed

Pluto seen by New Horizons, showing the bright heart-shaped Tombaugh Regio. Credit: NASA/JHUAPL/SwRI

Pluto seen by New Horizons, showing the bright heart-shaped Tombaugh Regio. Credit: NASA/JHUAPL/SwRI

While people argued over the label, the actual Pluto turned out to be spectacular. On July 14, 2015, New Horizons flew past it, the first close look ever. Pluto has a giant heart-shaped region, now named Tombaugh Regio. Part of it is a vast plain of mostly nitrogen ice, with glaciers that appear to flow. Around it rise mountains of water ice, up to about 11,000 feet high, so cold that the ice behaves like rock.

New Horizons also carried a passenger. Tombaugh died in 1997, and his family sent an ounce of his ashes on the mission, sealed in a 2-inch aluminum capsule. The inscription calls him the “discoverer of Pluto.” So the farm kid who found that tiny dot on a photographic plate finally got to go see it.

The label fight made millions of people feel either sad about Pluto or smugly superior about it. Almost nobody learned that it has glaciers.

The thing to take with you

When an argument just won’t die, online, at work, at Thanksgiving, stop and check whether the two sides even mean the same thing by the key word. A lot of internet fights are two people using one word for two different things, both sure the other one is an idiot.

The smug guy didn’t learn anything about Pluto. He learned a vote result and treated it like a law of nature. The planet didn’t change. We did.

Keep going: Lemmings Don’t Jump. Disney Pushed Them. is next in the series. Or go back to where it started: Everyone’s Wrong About the Flat Earth. Twice.

 

Corrections to the video

5:26: We said Alan Stern would “go on to lead” NASA’s mission to Pluto. He was already leading it, and New Horizons had launched seven months before the vote.

6:44: We said astronomers in 1850 counted twenty planets, thirteen of them asteroids. Thirteen asteroids plus the eight other planets makes 21, and the thirteenth wasn’t found until November 1850.

3:30: We said Pluto went from super-Earth to space pebble in fifty years. It took 63, from Lowell’s 1915 prediction to the 1978 discovery of Charon.

3:14: We said the estimate had fallen to a tenth of an Earth by 1948. That was Gerard Kuiper’s figure, reported in 1950. Calculations from planetary orbits still gave 0.82 Earth in 1955 and reached about a tenth only around 1971.

1:35: We said the vote to name Pluto was unanimous. That’s one account, which we couldn’t trace to a primary source. Another history says Lowell’s staff preferred Minerva and dropped it because an asteroid already had the name.

5:39: We stated flatly that Neptune hasn’t cleared its neighbourhood. That’s Alan Stern’s argument, and it’s disputed. Defenders read “cleared” as gravitational dominance, which Neptune passes by a wide margin and Pluto doesn’t.

5:45: We quoted Stern saying Earth couldn’t clear the Kuiper Belt. The quote is accurate, but the claim is disputed. Steven Soter says Earth at Pluto’s distance would have about the same dynamical power as Mercury or Mars, and would only marginally dominate its zone.

6:17: We called this “a dictionary fight with telescopes.” That undersells it. On measures of orbital dominance, a gap of four to five orders of magnitude separates the eight planets from everything else. Whether “planet” should stop at that gap is still a choice.

6:51: We said astronomers soon stopped calling asteroids planets because they were too small and too many. James Hilton dates the shift to the 1850s and 1860s. A 2019 paper by Metzger, Sykes, Stern and Runyon says it came in the 1950s, on geophysical grounds.

5:18: We gave the turnout without the result. One contemporary tally had the definition passing about 400 to 20. Daniel Fischer, the source of our 1 percent estimate, called it “a clear majority, almost consensus.”

Questions people ask

Why is Pluto not a planet?

Under the definition the International Astronomical Union adopted in 2006, a planet must orbit the Sun, be massive enough to become nearly round, and have cleared the neighborhood around its orbit. Pluto fails the third test, because it shares its zone with the icy bodies of the Kuiper Belt.

Is Pluto a planet?

It depends on the definition, which is the real argument. Under the IAU’s 2006 definition, Pluto is a dwarf planet, and a dwarf planet doesn’t count as a planet. Some planetary scientists, including New Horizons leader Alan Stern, reject that definition and still call Pluto a planet.

Did scientists discover something new about Pluto in 2006?

No. Nothing about Pluto changed. What drove the vote were earlier discoveries about its surroundings, especially Eris in 2005 and other icy worlds in the Kuiper Belt. Before 2006, “planet” had no official scientific definition.

How many astronomers voted on Pluto?

About 420, under 5 percent of the IAU’s membership, by holding up yellow cards in Prague on August 24, 2006. The resolution naming Pluto a dwarf planet passed 237 to 157, with 17 abstentions.

What does “cleared the neighborhood” mean?

It means a body has become gravitationally dominant in its orbital zone, not that its orbit is perfectly empty. Critics like Alan Stern call the wording vague and note that Jupiter and Neptune share their orbits with smaller bodies. Defenders point to a huge measured gap between the eight planets and everything else.

Has Pluto been made a planet again?

Not by the IAU. As of its 20th anniversary in August 2026, the 2006 definition still stood. The Illinois Senate did adopt a resolution in 2009 saying Pluto should be “reestablished with full planetary status,” but that has no scientific standing.

Sources

  • International Astronomical Union. Press release IAU0603 and Resolutions 5A and 6A (August 24, 2006).
  • Duncombe, R. L., and Seidelmann, P. K. (1980). A history of the determination of Pluto’s mass. Icarus 44.
  • Fischer, D. (2006). Inside the planet definition process. The Space Review.
  • Bennett, J. (2015). New Horizons Principal Investigator Still Considers Pluto a Planet. Popular Science.
  • Soter, S. (2006). What Is a Planet? The Astronomical Journal.
  • Margot, J.-L. (2015). A Quantitative Criterion for Defining Planets. The Astronomical Journal 150(6).
  • Hilton, J. L. When Did the Asteroids Become Minor Planets? U.S. Naval Observatory.
  • Metzger, P. T., Sykes, M. V., Stern, A., and Runyon, K. (2019). The Reclassification of Asteroids from Planets to Non-Planets. Icarus.
  • Astronomy. How asteroids lost their planethood (2022).
  • American Dialect Society. “Plutoed” voted 2006 Word of the Year.
  • Illinois General Assembly. Senate Resolution 46 (2009). See also Scientific American.
  • IFLScience (2026). The NASA chief’s comments, and who actually decides.
  • Cooper, K. (2026). It’s been 20 years since Pluto lost planet status. Space.com.
  • Kansas Historical Society. Clyde Tombaugh.
  • Wikipedia. Pluto (the naming story and the 1931 and 1948 mass figures).
  • Smithsonian Magazine. There’s Flowing Ice on Pluto (2015).
  • Spaceflight Now. The heart of Pluto in high-resolution (2015).
  • Associated Press, via ABC7. Astronomer’s ashes nearing icy world he discovered: Pluto (2015).

 

Pluto, Charon and New Horizons images: NASA/JHUAPL/SwRI. NASA imagery does not imply NASA endorsement.

October 25, 2026/by Allen Stafford
https://allenstafford.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Allen-Stafford-Think-Sharper-Logo.png 0 0 Allen Stafford https://allenstafford.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Allen-Stafford-Think-Sharper-Logo.png Allen Stafford2026-10-25 08:14:042026-11-05 11:34:34You Were Taught Wrong About Pluto. Here’s Why

Our Latest YouTube Videos

[youtube-feed feed=1]

Categories

© Copyright - Allen Stafford • Think clearly. Stay sovereign.
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to Youtube
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Accept settingsHide notification onlySettings

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refusing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

Accept settingsHide notification only