Developing the Optimal Value Proposition that Drives Market Success

Last Updated on

For a business to achieve market success, it must create superior value for their customers, collaborators, and the organization. Peter Drucker, the famed management theorist, stated that the purpose of business is to create a customer and that business enterprise has only two functions: marketing and innovation. Thus, the responsibility of creating value and winning customers falls on the shoulders of marketing.

The American Marketing Association defines marketing as the activity, set of institutions, and processes for creating, communicating, delivering, and exchange offerings that have value for customers, clients, partners, and society at large. 

Since market success, at the strategic level, is a result of creating superior value for customers, doing so is carried-out through the value proposition, which simply defines the value of a brand offering for a target market. Marketers seeking to design relevant value propositions for their brands must first understand the value exchange — value-based relationships — and define the relationships between the customers, collaborators, company, and competitors in any given market.

As an example, consider the relationship a manufacturer has with a retailer and the relationship the retailer has with the target customer. The retailer (a collaborator) partners with the manufacturer (the company) to deliver products (a value) to the target customer. The customer receives value from the manufacturer by way of the product and value from the retailer by way of delivery and service of the product. Both the manufacturer and retailer receive value from the customer through the revenue generated by the customer. Additionally, the retailer receives value from the manufacturer through varied trade promotions granted by the manufacturer. The manufacturer receives value from the retailer through the services performed by the retailer on behalf of the manufacturer, i.e. product advertising and promotions (See diagram below).

Value Proposition value chain strategic marketing diagram

The symbiotic relationship among the company, collaborators, and customers reflects only the company side of the value exchange. Marketers need to be aware of competitors who often work with the same collaborators and target the same customers. Both the competitors and company’s value exchange are balanced. Thus, to be successful, marketers must craft optimal value propositions —value that is balanced — for customers, collaborators, and the company.

Before a balanced value proposition is created, the marketer must evaluate the market potential of an offering by answering three critical questions:

  • Does the offering create superior value for target customers relative to the competitive offerings? In other words, are the products and services offered perceived to be superior to that of the competition?
  • Does the offering create superior value for the company’s collaborators relative to what the competition is offering? Is the manufacturer (the company) providing a better overall value to the retailers in the way of incentives or bonuses than the competition?
  • Does the offering create superior value for the company relative to the other options the company must generate in order to pursue this offering? Does the value the company receives outweigh the costs to deliver the product or service?

In a recent survey on, 87% of global brand managers and CMOs agreed that an aspect of their overall brand strategy is to include brand story and value propositions as part of their strategies. Yet, less than half (46%) claimed to have a deep understanding of their audience personas, the very thing that helps marketers identify customer values that lead to the creation of effective value propositions.

To truly develop the optimum value proposition, marketers need to fully understand their target audience; personas, then be able to answer the three critical questions (above) surrounding an offering. If the company’s offerings create superior value for the customer, collaborator, and company relative to the competitors — and to other options, the company must generate in order to provide the offering — then the company is positioned to achieve market superiority.


Adkins, Amy (2016, March 31), Biggest Driver of B2B Success: Meaningful Customer Impact. Retrieved from Accessed April 7, 2017.

“Definition of Marketing.” American Marketing Association. N.p., July 2013. Web. 8 Apr. 2017. Retrieved from Accessed April 7, 2017.

MarketingCharts staff (2017, March 23). Which Components Are Essential to Marketers’ Brand Strategies? Retrieved from Accessed April 8, 2017.

Trout, Jack (2006, July 3). Peter Drucker on Marketing. Retrieved from Accessed April 9, 2017.

Chernev, A. Strategic Marketing Management. Chicago, IL. Cerrebellum Press; 2014

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.